All posts by : admin

Posted by Cheng Xing and Michael Broughton, Google

Training large machine learning models is a core ability for TensorFlow. Over the years, scale has become an important feature in many modern machine learning systems for NLP, image recognition, drug discovery etc. Making use of multiple machines to boost computational power and throughput has led to great advances in the field. Similarly in quantum computing and quantum machine learning, the availability of more machine resources speeds up the simulation of larger quantum states and more complex systems. In this tutorial you will walk through how to use TensorFlow and TensorFlow quantum to conduct large scale and distributed QML simulations. Running larger simulations with greater FLOP/s counts unlocks new possibilities for research that otherwise wouldn’t be possible at smaller scales. In the figure below we have outlined approximate scaling capabilities for several different hardware settings for quantum simulation.

Running distributed workloads often comes with infrastructure complexity, but we can use Kubernetes to simplify this process. Kubernetes is an open source container orchestration system, and it is a proven platform to effectively manage large-scale workloads. While it is possible to have a multi-worker setup with a cluster of physical or virtual machines, Kubernetes offers many advantages, including:

• Service discovery – workers can easily identify each other using well-known DNS names, rather than manually configuring IP destinations.
• Automatic bin-packing – your workloads are automatically scheduled on different machines based on resource demand and current consumption.
• Automated rollouts and rollbacks – the number of worker replicas can be changed by changing a configuration, and Kubernetes automatically adds/removes workers in response and schedules in machines where resources are available.

This tutorial guides you through a TensorFlow Quantum multi-worker setup using Google Cloud products, including Google Kubernetes Engine, a managed Kubernetes platform. You will have the chance to take the single-worker Quantum Convolutional Neural Network (QCNN) tutorial in TensorFlow Quantum and augment it for multi-worker training.

From our experiments in the multi-worker setting, training a 23-qubit QCNN with 1,000 training examples, which corresponds to roughly 3,000 circuits simulated using full state vector simulation takes 5 minutes per epoch on a 32 node (512 vCPU) cluster, which costs a few US dollars. By comparison, the same training job on a single-worker would take roughly 4 hours per epoch. Pushing things a little bit farther, hundreds of thousands of 30-qubit circuits could be run in a few hours using more than 10,000 virtual CPUs which could have taken weeks to run in a single-worker setting. The actual performance and cost may vary depending on your cloud setup, such as VM machine type, total cluster running time, etc. Before performing larger experiments, we recommend starting with a small cluster first, like the one used in this tutorial.

The source code for this tutorial is available in the TensorFlow Quantum GitHub repository. README.md contains the quickest way to get this tutorial up and running. This tutorial will instead focus on walk through each step in detail, to help you understand the underlying concepts and integrate them with your own projects. Let’s get started!

1. Setting up Infrastructure in Google Cloud

The first step is to create the infrastructure resources in Google Cloud. If you have an existing Google Cloud environment, the exact steps might vary, due to organizational policy constraints for example. This is a guideline to the most common set of necessary steps. Note that you will be charged for Google Cloud resources you create, and here is a summary of billable resources used in this tutorial. If you are a new Google Cloud user, you are eligible for $300 in credits. If you are part of an academic institution, you may be eligible for Google Cloud research credits.

You will be running several shell commands in this tutorial. For that, you can use either a local Unix shell available on your computer or the Cloud Shell, which already contains many of the tools mentioned later.

A script automating the steps below is available in setup.sh. This section walks through every step in detail, and if this is your first time using Google Cloud, we recommend that you walk through the entire section. If you prefer to automate the Google Cloud setup process and skip this section:

• Open setup.sh and configure parameter values inside.
• Run ./setup.sh infra.

In this tutorial, you will use a few Google Cloud products:

• Kubernetes Engine (GKE). This is the main infrastructure platform executing your QCNN jobs in this tutorial.
• Cloud Storage, to store data from your QCNN jobs.
• Container Registry, to store container images.

To get your cloud environment ready, first follow these quick start guides:

• Quickstart for Container Registry
• Quickstart for Kubernetes Engine

For purposes of this tutorial, you could stop the Kubernetes Engine quickstart right before the instructions for creating a cluster. In addition, install gsutil, the Cloud Storage command-line tool (if you are using Cloud Shell, gsutil is already installed):

gcloud components install gsutil

For reference, shell commands throughout the tutorial will refer to these variables. Some of them will make more sense later on in the tutorial in the context of each command.

• ${CLUSTER_NAME}: your preferred Kubernetes cluster name on Google Kubernetes Engine.
• ${PROJECT}: your Google Cloud project ID.
• ${NUM_NODES}: the number of VMs in your cluster.
• ${MACHINE_TYPE}: the machine type of VMs. This controls the amount of CPU and memory resources for each VM.
• ${SERVICE_ACCOUNT_NAME}: The name of both the Google Cloud IAM service account and the associated Kubernetes service account.
• ${ZONE}: Google Cloud zone for the Kubernetes cluster.
• ${BUCKET_REGION}: Google Cloud region for Google Cloud Storage bucket.
• ${BUCKET_NAME}: Name of the Google Cloud Storage bucket for storing training output.

To ensure you have permissions to run cloud operations in the rest of the tutorial, make sure either you have the IAM role of owner, or all of the following roles:

• container.admin
• iam.serviceAccountAdmin
• storage.admin

To check your roles, run:

gcloud projects get-iam-policy ${PROJECT}

with your Google Cloud project ID and search for your user account.

After you’ve completed the quickstart guides, run this command to create a Kubernetes cluster:

gcloud container clusters create ${CLUSTER_NAME} --workload-pool=${PROJECT}.svc.id.goog --num-nodes=${NUM_NODES} --machine-type=${MACHINE_TYPE} --zone=${ZONE} --preemptible

with your Google Cloud project ID and preferred cluster name.

--num-nodes is the number of Compute Engine virtual machines backing your Kubernetes cluster. This is not necessarily the same as the number of worker replicas you’d like to have for your QCNN job, as Kubernetes is able to schedule multiple replicas on the same node, provided that the node has enough CPU and memory resources. If you are trying this tutorial for the first time, we recommend 2 nodes.

--machine-type specifies the VM machine type. If you are trying this tutorial for the first time, we recommend “n1-standard-2”, with 2 vCPUs and 7.5GB of memory.

--zone is the Google Cloud zone where you’d like to run your cluster (for example “us-west1-a”).

--workload-pool enables the GKE Workload Identity feature, which ties Kubernetes service accounts with Google Cloud IAM service accounts. In order to have fine-grained access control, an IAM service account is recommended to access various Google Cloud products. Here you’ll create a service account to be used by your QCNN jobs. Kubernetes service account is the mechanism to inject the credentials of this IAM service account into your worker container.

--preemptible uses Compute Engine Preemptible VMs to back the Kubernetes cluster. They are up to 80% lower in cost compared to regular VMs, with the tradeoff that a VM may be preempted at any time, which will terminate the training process. This is well-suited for short-running training sessions with large clusters.

You can then create an IAM service account:

gcloud iam service-accounts create ${SERVICE_ACCOUNT_NAME}

and integrate it with Workload Identity:

gcloud iam service-accounts add-iam-policy-binding --role roles/iam.workloadIdentityUser --member "serviceAccount:${PROJECT}.svc.id.goog[default/${SERVICE_ACCOUNT_NAME}]" ${SERVICE_ACCOUNT_NAME}@${PROJECT}.iam.gserviceaccount.com

Now create a storage bucket, which is the basic container to store your data:

gsutil mb -p ${PROJECT} -l ${BUCKET_REGION} -b on gs://${BUCKET_NAME}

using your preferred bucket name. The bucket name is globally unique, so we recommend including your project name as part of the bucket name. The bucket region is recommended to be the region containing your cluster’s zone. The region of a zone is the part of the zone name without the section after the last hyphen. For example, the region of zone “us-west1-a” is “us-west1”.

To make your Cloud Storage data accessible by your QCNN jobs, give permissions to your IAM service account:

gsutil iam ch serviceAccount:${SERVICE_ACCOUNT_NAME}@${PROJECT}.iam.gserviceaccount.com:roles/storage.admin gs://${BUCKET_NAME}

2. Preparing Your Kubernetes Cluster

With the cloud environment set up, you can now install the necessary Kubernetes tools into the cluster. You’ll need tf-operator, a component from KubeFlow. KubeFlow is a toolkit for running machine learning workloads on Kubernetes, and tf-operator is a subcomponent which simplifies the management of TensorFlow jobs. tf-operator can be installed separately without the larger KubeFlow installation.

To install tf-operator, run:

docker pull k8s.gcr.io/kustomize/kustomize:v3.10.0
docker run k8s.gcr.io/kustomize/kustomize:v3.10.0 build "github.com/kubeflow/tf-operator.git/manifests/overlays/standalone?ref=v1.1.0" | kubectl apply -f -

(Note that tf-operator uses Kustomize to manage its deployment files, so it needs to be installed here as well)

3. Training with MultiWorkerMirroredStrategy

You can now take the QCNN code found on the TensorFlow Quantum research branch and prepare it to run in a distributed fashion. Let’s clone the source code:

git clone https://github.com/tensorflow/quantum.git && cd quantum && git checkout origin/research && cd qcnn_multiworker

Or, if you are using SSH keys to authenticate to GitHub:

git clone git@github.com:tensorflow/quantum.git && cd quantum && git checkout origin/research && cd qcnn_multiworker

Code Setup

The training directory contains the necessary pieces for performing distributed training of your QCNN. The combination of training/qcnn.py and common/qcnn_common.py is the same as the hybrid QCNN example in TensorFlow Quantum, but with a few feature additions:

• Training can now optionally leverage multiple machines with tf.distribute.MultiWorkerMirroredStrategy.
• TensorBoard integration, which you will explore in more detail in the next section.

MultiWorkerMirroredStrategy is the mechanism in TensorFlow to perform synchronized distributed training. Your existing model has been augmented for distributed training with just a few extra lines of code.

At the beginning of training/qcnn.py, we set up MultiWorkerMirroredStrategy:

strategy = tf.distribute.MultiWorkerMirroredStrategy()

In the model preparation step, we then pass in this strategy as an argument:

... = qcnn_common.prepare_model(strategy)

Each worker of our QCNN distributed training job will run a copy of this Python code. Every worker needs to know the network endpoint of all other workers. The TF_CONFIG environment variable is typically used for this purpose, but in our case, the tf-operator injects it automatically behind the scenes.

After the model is trained, weights are uploaded to your Cloud Storage bucket to be accessed later by the inference job.

if task_type == 'worker' and task_id == 0:
    qcnn_weights_path='/tmp/qcnn_weights.h5'
    qcnn_model.save_weights(qcnn_weights_path)
    upload_blob(args.weights_gcs_bucket, qcnn_weights_path, f'qcnn_weights.h5')

Kubernetes Deployment Setup

Before proceeding to the Kubernetes deployment setup and launching your workers, several parameters need to be configured in the tutorial source code to match your own setup. The provided script, setup.sh, can be used to simplify this process.

Open setup.sh and configure parameter values inside, if you haven’t already done so in a previous step. Then run

./setup.sh param

At this point, the remaining steps in this section can be performed in one command:

make training

The rest of this section walks through the Kubernetes setup in detail.

Prior to running as containers in Kubernetes, the QCNN job needs to be packaged as a container image using Docker and uploaded to the Container Registry. The Dockerfile contains the specification for the image. To build and upload the image, run:

docker build -t gcr.io/${PROJECT}/qcnn .
docker push gcr.io/${PROJECT}/qcnn

Next, you’ll complete the Workload Identity setup by creating the Kubernetes service account using common/sa.yaml. This service account will be used by the QCNN containers.

apiVersion: v1
kind: ServiceAccount
metadata:
  annotations:
    iam.gke.io/gcp-service-account: ${SERVICE_ACCOUNT_NAME}@${PROJECT}.iam.gserviceaccount.com
  name: ${SERVICE_ACCOUNT_NAME}

The annotation tells GKE this Kubernetes service account should be bound to the IAM service account you created previously. Let’s create this service account:

kubectl apply -f common/sa.yaml

The last step is to create the distributed training job. training/qcnn.yaml contains the Kubernetes specifications for your job. In Kubernetes, multiple containers with related functions are grouped into a single entity called a Pod, which is the most fundamental unit of work that can be scheduled. Typically, users leverage existing resource types such as Deployment and Job to create and manage workloads. You’ll instead use TFJob (as specified in the `kind` field), which is not a Kubernetes built-in resource type but rather a Custom Resource provided by the tf-operator, making it easier to work with TensorFlow workloads.

Notably, the TFJob spec contains the field tfReplicaSpecs.Worker, which lets you configure a MultiWorkerMirroredStrategy worker. Values of PS (parameter server), Chief, and Evaluator are also supported for asynchronous and other forms of distributed training. Under the hood, tf-operator creates two Kubernetes resources for each worker replica:

• A Pod, using the Pod spec template at tfReplicaSpecs.Worker.template. This runs the container you’ve built previously on Kubernetes.
• A Service, which exposes a well-known network endpoint visible within the Kubernetes cluster to give access to the worker’s gRPC training server. Other workers can communicate with its server by simply pointing to <service_name>:<port> (the alternative form of <service_name>.<service_namespace>.svc:<port> works as well).

The TFJob generates one Service and Pod per worker replica. Once the TFJob is updated, changes are reflected in the underlying Services and Pods. Worker status is also reported in the TFJob.

The Service exposes worker servers to the rest of the cluster. Each worker communicates with other workers by using the destination worker’s Service name as the DNS name.

Within the worker spec, there are a few notable fields:

• replicas: Number of worker replicas. It’s possible for multiple replicas to be scheduled on the same node, so this number is not limited to the number of nodes.
• template: the Pod spec template for each worker replica
  • serviceAccountName: this gives the Pod access to the Kubernetes service account.
  • container:
    • image: Points to the Container Registry image you’ve built previously.
    • command: the container’s entry point command.
    • arg: command-line arguments.
    • ports: opens up one port for workers to communicate with each other, and another port for profiling.
  • affinity: this tells Kubernetes that you prefer to schedule worker Pods on different nodes as much as possible, to maximize resource utilization.

To create the TFJob:

kubectl apply -f training/qcnn.yaml

Inspecting the Deployment

Congratulations! Your distributed training is now underway. To check the job’s status, run kubectl get pods a few times (or add -w to stream the output). Eventually you should see there are the same number of qcnn-worker Pods as your replicas parameter, and they all have status Running:

NAME            READY   STATUS    RESTARTS
qcnn-worker-0   1/1     Running   0
qcnn-worker-1   1/1     Running   0

To access the worker’s log output, run:

kubectl logs <worker_pod_name>

or add -f to stream the output. The output of qcnn-worker-0 looks like this:

…
I tensorflow/core/distributed_runtime/rpc/grpc_server_lib.cc:411] Started server with target: grpc:/
/qcnn-worker-0.default.svc:2222
…
I tensorflow/core/profiler/rpc/profiler_server.cc:46] Profiler server listening on [::]:2223 selecte
d port:2223
…
Epoch 1/50
…
4/4 [==============================] - 7s 940ms/step - loss: 0.9387 - accuracy: 0.0000e+00 - val_loss: 0.7432 - val_accuracy: 0.0000e+00
…
I tensorflow/core/profiler/lib/profiler_session.cc:71] Profiler session collecting data.
I tensorflow/core/profiler/lib/profiler_session.cc:172] Profiler session tear down.
…
Epoch 50/50
4/4 [==============================] - 1s 222ms/step - loss: 0.1468 - accuracy: 0.4101 - val_loss: 0.2043 - val_accuracy: 0.4583
File /tmp/qcnn_weights.h5 uploaded to qcnn_weights.h5.

The output of qcnn-worker-1 should be similar except the last line is missing. The chief worker (worker 0) is responsible for saving weights of the entire model.

You can also verify that model weights are saved by visiting the Storage Browser in Cloud Console and browsing through the storage bucket you created previously.

To delete the training job, run

kubectl delete -f training/qcnn.yaml

4. Understanding Training Performance Using TensorBoard

TensorBoard is TensorFlow’s visualization toolkit. By integrating your TensorFlow Quantum model with TensorBoard, you get many visualizations about your model out of the box, such as training loss & accuracy, visualizing the model graph, and program profiling.

Code Setup

To enable TensorBoard for your job, create a TensorBoard callback and pass it into model.fit():

tensorboard_callback = tf.keras.callbacks.TensorBoard(log_dir=args.logdir,
                                                      histogram_freq=1,
                                                      update_freq=1,
                                                      profile_batch='10, 20')
…
    history = qcnn_model.fit(x=train_excitations,
                             y=train_labels,
                             batch_size=32,
                             epochs=50,
                             verbose=1,
                             validation_data=(test_excitations, test_labels),
                             callbacks=[tensorboard_callback])

The profile_batch parameter enables the TensorFlow Profiler in programmatic mode, which samples the program during the training step range you specify here. You can also enable the sampling mode,

tf.profiler.experimental.server.start(args.profiler_port)

which allows on-demand profiling initiated either by a different program or through the TensorBoard UI.

TensorBoard Features

Here we’ll highlight a subset of TensorBoard’s many powerful features used in this tutorial. Check out the TensorBoard guide to learn more.

Loss and Accuracy

Loss is the quantity that the model aims to minimize during training, computed via a loss function. Accuracy is the fraction of samples during training where predictions match labels. The loss metric is exported by default. To enable the accuracy metric, add the following to the model.compile() step:

qcnn_model.compile(..., metrics=[‘accuracy’])

Custom Metrics

In addition to loss and accuracy, TensorBoard also supports custom metrics. For example, the tutorial code exports the QCNN readout tensor as a histogram.

Profiler

The TensorFlow Profiler is a helpful tool in debugging performance bottlenecks in your model training job.

In this tutorial, we use both the programmatic mode, in which profiling is done for a predefined training step range, as well as the sampling mode, in which profiling can be done on-demand. For a MultiWorkerMirroredStrategy setup, currently programmatic mode only outputs profiling data from the chief (worker 0), whereas sampling mode is able to profile all workers.

When you first open the Profiler, the data displayed is from the programmatic mode. The overview page gives you a sense of how long training took during each step. This will act as a reference as you experiment with different methods of improving training performance, whether that’s by scaling infrastructure (adding more VMs to the cluster, using VMs with more CPU and memory, integrating with hardware accelerators) or improving code efficiency.

The trace viewer gives the duration breakdown of all the training instructions under the hood, providing a detailed view to identify execution time bottlenecks.

Kubernetes Deployment Setup

To view the TensorBoard UI, you can create a TensorBoard instance in Kubernetes. The Kubernetes setup is in training/tensorboard.yaml. This file contains two objects:

• A Deployment containing 1 Pod replica of the same worker container image, but run with a TensorBoard command: tensorboard --logdir=gs://${BUCKET_NAME}/${LOGDIR_NAME} --port=5001 --bind_all
• A Service creating a network load balancer to make the TensorBoard UI accessible on the Internet, so you can view it in your browser.

It is also possible to run a local instance of TensorBoard on your workstation by pointing --logdir to the same Cloud Storage bucket, although additional IAM permissions setup is required.

Create this Kubernetes setup:

kubectl apply -f training/tensorboard.yaml

In the output of kubectl get pods, you should see there’s a Pod with the prefix qcnn-tensorboard which is eventually in Running status. To get the IP address of the TensorBoard instance, run

kubectl get svc tensorboard-service -w

NAME                  TYPE           CLUSTER-IP     EXTERNAL-IP     PORT(S)
tensorboard-service   LoadBalancer   10.123.240.9   <pending>   5001:32200/TCP

The load balancer takes some time to provision so you may not see the IP right away. Once it’s available, go to <ip>:5001 in your browser to access the TensorBoard UI.

With TensorFlow 2.4 and higher, it’s possible to profile multiple workers in sampling mode: workers can be profiled while a training job is running, by clicking “Capture Profile” in the Tensorboard Profiler and “Profile Service URL” to qcnn-worker-<replica_id>:2223. To enable this, the profiler port needs to be exposed by the worker service. The tutorial source code provides a script which patches all worker Services generated by the TFJob with a profiler port. Run

training/apply_profiler_ports.sh

Note that the need to manually patch Services is temporary, and there is currently planned work in tf-operator to support specifying additional ports in the TFJob.

5. Running Inference

After completing the distributed training job, model weights are stored in your Cloud Storage bucket. You can then use these weights to construct an inference program, and then create an inference job in the Kubernetes cluster. It is also possible to run an inference program on your local workstation, although it requires additional IAM permissions to grant access to Cloud Storage.

Code Setup

Inference source code is available in the inference/ directory. The main file, qcnn_inference.py, mostly reuses the model construction code in common/qcnn_common.py, but loads model weights from your Cloud Storage bucket instead:

qcnn_weights_path = '/tmp/qcnn_weights.h5'
download_blob(args.weights_gcs_bucket, args.weights_gcs_path, qcnn_weights_path)
qcnn_model.load_weights(qcnn_weights_path)

It then applies the model to a test set and computes the mean squared error.

results = qcnn_model(test_excitations).numpy().flatten()
loss = tf.keras.losses.mean_squared_error(test_labels, results)

Kubernetes Deployment Setup

The remaining steps in this section can be performed in one command:

make inference

The inference program is built into the Docker image from the training step, so you don’t need to build a new image here. The inference job spec, inference/inference.yaml, contains a Job with its Pod spec pointing to the image but executes qcnn_inference.py instead. Run kubectl apply -f inference/inference.yaml to create the job.

The Pod prefixed with inference-qcnn should eventually be in Running status (kubectl get pods). In the log output of the inference Pod (kubectl logs <pod_name>), the mean squared error should be close to the final loss shown in the TensorBoard UI.

…
Blob qcnn_weights.h5 downloaded to /tmp/qcnn_weights.h5.
[-0.8220097   0.40201923 -0.82856977  0.46476707 -1.1281478   0.23317486
  0.00584182  1.3351855   0.35139582 -0.09958048  1.2205497  -1.3038696
  1.4065738  -1.1120421  -0.01021352  1.4553616  -0.70309246 -0.0518395
  1.4699622  -1.3712595  -0.01870352  1.2939589   1.2865802   0.847203
  0.3149605   1.1705848  -1.0051676   1.2537074  -0.2943283  -1.3489063
 -1.4727883   1.4566276   1.3417912   0.9123422   0.2942805  -0.791862
  1.2984066  -1.1139404   1.4648925  -1.6311806  -0.17530376  0.70148027
 -1.0084027   0.09898916  0.4121615   0.62743163 -1.4237025  -0.6296255 ]
Test Labels
[-1  1 -1  1 -1  1  1  1  1 -1  1 -1  1 -1  1  1 -1 -1  1 -1 -1  1  1  1
  1  1 -1  1 -1 -1 -1  1  1  1 -1 -1  1 -1  1 -1 -1  1 -1  1  1  1 -1 -1]
Mean squared error:  tf.Tensor(0.29677835, shape=(), dtype=float32)

6. Cleaning Up

And this wraps up our journey through distributed training! After you are done experimenting with the tutorial, this section walks you through the steps to clean up Google Cloud resources.

First, remove the Kubernetes deployments. Run:

make delete-inference
kubectl delete -f training/tensorboard.yaml

and, if you haven’t done so already,

make delete-training

Then, delete the GKE cluster. This deletes the underlying VMs as well.

gcloud container clusters delete ${CLUSTER_NAME} --zone=${ZONE}

Next, delete the training data in your Google Cloud Storage.

gsutil rm -r gs://${BUCKET_NAME}

And lastly, remove the worker container image from Container Registry following these instructions using the Cloud Console. Look for the image name qcnn.

Next Steps

Now that you’ve tried out the multi-worker setup, try setting it up with your project! As all the tools mentioned in this tutorial continue to grow, best practices for training with multiple workers will change over time. Check back on the tutorial directory in the TensorFlow Quantum GitHub repository for updates!

As you continue to scale your experiment, you might eventually hit infrastructure limitations that require advanced configuration of the technologies used in this tutorial due to the complexity of working in a distributed environment. For a deeper dive into some of them, check out these resources:

• Distributed training with TensorFlow
• TensorBoard guide
• The TensorFlow Blog
• Kubernetes documentation
  • Managing Resources for Containers, as large training jobs are typically resource-constrained.
• Google Kubernetes Engine Documentation
• Google Cloud Blog

If you are interested in conducting large scale QML research in Tensorflow Quantum, check out our research credit application page to apply for cloud credits on Google Cloud.Read More

A guest post by James Bartlett and Zain Asgar of Pixie.

At Pixie, our goal is to enable developers to quickly understand and debug production systems. We achieve this by providing developers easy access to an assortment of metric and log data from their production system. For example, we collect structured information about CPU and memory usage for each process in their system, as well as many types of unstructured data (for example, the body of an HTTP request, or the error message from a program).

These are just two examples, we collect many other types of data, as well. For this blog post, we will focus on the vast amounts of unstructured data we collect in Pixie such as HTTP request/response bodies. We foresee a future where this unstructured machine data can be queried as easily and efficiently as the structured data. To achieve this, we leverage state-of-the-art NLP techniques to learn the structure of the data.

In this article, we’d like to share our experience and efforts here, in the hopes they are useful to inform your thinking on similar problems.

HTTP clustering

Suppose a developer using Pixie wanted to get an idea of which types of HTTP requests are particularly slow. Instead of forcing the developer to sift through many individual HTTP requests by hand, we can instead cluster the HTTP requests semantically and then show them a timeseries of latencies for each type of semantically clustered request. To demonstrate this, let’s walk through the end result and then we’ll come back to how we got to this point. We will use Pixie to explore a demo application called Online Boutique. Once we have Pixie deployed to a kubernetes cluster running Online Boutique, we can start to explore. For example, we can look at a graph of the network connections within the Online Boutique application:

As you can see in the service graph, there’s a frontend service that handles incoming requests and sends them to their respective microservices. So let’s delve into the HTTP requests sent to the frontend service and their corresponding latencies.

From this small sample of requests, it’s not immediately clear what’s going on. It looks like the requests with `email=…?address=…` are much slower than the others, but we can’t be sure these examples weren’t just outliers. Instead of looking at more data, let’s use our soon-to-be-explained unstructured text clustering techniques, to cluster the HTTP requests semantically by the contents of their bodies.

Here you can see a plot of the average 99th percentile response latency for requests for each semantic cluster. Using this view, you can quickly determine the three broad categories of requests coming into the frontend service, as well as the latency profiles of those requests. Immediately, we see that the “email” cluster of requests has significantly higher average p99 latency than the other clusters, and we see that the “product” cluster has occasional latency spikes. Both of these are actionable insights we can debug further. Now let’s dive in and discuss how we got to this point.

Model Development Details

Requirements

Since our models will be deployed on customers’ production clusters, they must be lightweight and performant; ideally fast enough to handle data at line rate with minimal CPU overhead. Any training on customer data must occur on the customer cluster to maintain data isolation guarantees. Furthermore, since the data plane is entirely contained on customer clusters, we have strict storage limitations for data, so we must leverage ML techniques to intelligently sample the data we collect.

Dataset

Due to our stringent data isolation requirements we’re using the loghub dataset to bootstrap our model training. This dataset is a collection of log messages from various contexts (Android sys logs, Apache Server logs, supercomputer/HPC logs, etc). To test the models generalization to unseen log formats, we reserved the Android log data for testing, and trained on the remainder of the log data.

We use Google’s SentencePiece to tokenize the log messages. In particular, we use their implementation of unigram language model based subword tokenization with a vocab size of 16k. The following image shows a word cloud of all 16k vocabulary subword pieces that are generated by our tokenization. The size of the words indicate the frequency in the dataset.

Word cloud showing vocabulary subword pieces from Logpai Loghub machine log dataset tokenization.

This word cloud provides insight into the biases of our dataset. For example, about 30% of the data is Windows logs, as you can see by the high frequency of the token “windows”, and “microsoft”. Also, if you have a keen eye, you might think we have a lot of frowny faces in our data set, but in fact “):” is almost always preceded by an opening parenthesis, as in the following examples:

[Thu Jan 26 12:23:07 2006] [error] config.update(): Can't create vm
[Fri Jan 27 11:55:16 2006] [error] [client 202.143.128.18] client sent HTTP/1.1 request without hostname (see RFC2616 section 14.23): /

Model Architecture

Using this tokenized dataset, we train a self-attention based model using left-to-right next word prediction (à la OpenAI’s GPT models). Left-to-right next word prediction is the task of trying to predict the next token given a sequence of prior context tokens. The left-to-right part distinguishes it from BERT style models that use bidirectional context (we will try bidirectional models in the future). This TensorFlow tutorial demonstrates training of a similar architecture, the only difference being we drop the encoder side of the architecture in the tutorial.

The architecture we use is displayed in the figure below. We have 6 decoder blocks, each with a self-attention layer and a feed-forward layer. Note that, for simplicity, the diagram leaves out the skip connections over the self-attention and feed-forward layers, as well as the layer normalizations that go with those skip connections.

GPT-style language model architecture

All in all, this architecture has 6.47M parameters, making it quite small in comparison to state-of-the-art language models. DistillBERT, for instance, has 66M parameters. On the other hand, the largest version of GPT-3 has 175B parameters.

We trained this architecture for 10 epochs with roughly 100 million unique log messages per epoch. After each epoch, we ran the model on a validation set and the model from the epoch with the highest validation accuracy was used as the final model. We achieved a test accuracy of 63.13% for next word prediction on the holdout Android log data. Given that we haven’t yet explored hyperparameter tuning, or other optimizations, this level of accuracy is a promising starting point.

We now have a way to predict future tokens in machine log data from context, with somewhat decent accuracy. However, this doesn’t immediately help us with our original goal of extracting structured features from the data. To further this goal, we will explore the feature space generated by the language model, rather than the predictions of the language model.

The goal is to transform our complicated data space into a fixed-dimensional feature space which we can then use for subsequent tasks. In order to do this we need to transform the outputs of the language model into a fixed-dimensional vector, which we will call the feature vector. One way to do this comes from BERT style models.

With BERT style models the way to extend the pre-trained language model to supervised tasks is to add a fully connected network on the output of the <CLS> (or <s>) token of the sentence, and then fine-tune the model with the fully-connected network on some classification task (this is illustrated in the figure below). This leads to a natural feature vector as the output prior to the softmax layer.

Alammar, J (2018). The Illustrated Transformer [Blog post]. Retrieved from https://jalammar.github.io/illustrated-transformer/

We plan to explore this method in the future, however for now we would like to see what results we can get without adding any extra supervision. This requires a heuristic approach to turn our sequence of outputs into a fixed-length vector. One way to do this is to use a max-pooling operator on the sequence dimension of the output. Suppose our language model outputs a sequence of 256-dimensional vectors, then a max-pooling on the sequence dimension will output a single 256-dimensional vector, where each dimension is the maximum value of that dimension across all outputs in the sequence. The idea behind this approach is that neurons that have stronger responses are more important to include in the final representation.

Results

We can test how well this method works for clustering on a subset of the loghub data that I’ve hand labeled into semantic clusters. Below are three of the log messages in the hand labelled test data set. The first two are labelled to be in the same semantic cluster, since both relate to failures to find files, the last is from a different cluster, since it’s an unrelated message about flushing data.

[Wed Nov 09 22:30:05 2005] [error] [client 216.138.114.25] script not found or unable to stat: /var/www/cgi-bin/awstats.p

[Sat Jan 28 19:29:29 2006] [error] [client 211.154.174.50] File does not exist: /var/www/html/modules

20171230-12:25:37:318|Step_StandStepCounter|30002312|flush sensor data

Using the hand-labelled test set, we can measure how well the model separates the different clusters. To do this, we use the KMeans algorithm to generate a clustering based on the output of the model, and then compare this clustering to the hand-labelled clustering. On this test set, the model’s adjusted rand score, a metric where 0.0 is random labelling and 1.0 is perfect labelling, was 0.53. As with next word prediction accuracy, the performance isn’t great but a good starting point.

We can also view a low-dimensional representation of the feature space for the model, using PCA to reduce the dimensionality to two. The figures below show the first two PCA dimensions of the embeddings for each point in the test data set. The colors represent the semantic cluster the point belongs to. Note that since these are plots in a two-dimensional subspace of the embedding space, the absolute position of points carries little meaning, more meaning is derived from the tightness of each of the clusters. In the figure below, we can see that the model separates some of the classes reasonably well, but fails on others.

2-dimensional representation of the feature space of the model.

Using this method, we should be able to cluster unstructured data in Pixie, and tag it with its semantic cluster ID, hence extracting a structured feature from our unstructured data. This particular feature is, as yet, not very human-interpretable, but we will get to that later.

Inference

So let’s try to implement this method within the Pixie system. In order to do that we first need to convert our model into TensorFlow Lite and then load it into the Pixie execution engine. We decided to use TensorFlow Lite because we need to minimize overhead as much as possible, and in the future we would like the flexibility to deploy to heterogeneous edge devices including Raspberry PI’s and ARM microcontrollers.

Converting to TensorFlow Lite is pretty simple. We create a TF function for our model and call the builtin converter to generate a tensorflow lite model protobuf file:

model = tf.keras.models.load_model(model_path)
@tf.function(input_signature=[tf.TensorSpec([1, max_length], dtype=tf.int32)
def pred_fn(encoded_text):
	# Create a mask that masks out 0 tokens, and future tokens for next word prediction.
	mask = create_padded_lookahead_mask(max_length)
	# Our saved model outputs both its next word predictions, and the activations of its final layer. We only use the activations of the final layer for clustering purposes.
	model_preds, last_layer_output = model([encoded_text, mask], training=False)
	# Max pool over the seq dimension.
	return tf.reduce_max(last_layer_output, axis=1)

converter = tf.lite.TFLiteConverter.from_concrete_functions([fn.get_concrete_function()])
tflite_model = converter.convert()

Pixie’s query engine allows querying and manipulating data collected by Pixie. This engine already has a KMeans operator, so all we need to do is load our tflite model into the engine, and then write a custom PxL script (a script in Pixie’s scripting language based on Python/Pandas) to cluster our data. We are working on a public API to load in custom ML models into the engine, but for now we will use some internal features to do that. Once the model is loaded in, we can use it on any unstructured data in the Pixie Platform.

Some of the areas we are currently exploring include our vision of federated differentially-private training of models, bidirectional language models ala BERT, compression schemes for unstructured data based on learned structural representations of the data, and anomaly detection on unstructured data

Our goal on the Pixie ML team is to harness ML to simplify developers’ access to monitoring data, while operating in heterogeneous edge environments. If any of this interests you, or you have other questions feel free to join our slack group.

Pixie is an open-source project that gives you instant visibility into your application. It provides access to metrics, events, traces and logs without changing code. Pixie is in the process of being contributed to the CNCF (Cloud Native Compute Foundation). Pixie was originally created at Pixie Labs, Inc., but contributed to open source by New Relic, Inc.

James is a software engineer at the New Relic on the Pixie Team. He was a founding engineer at Pixie Labs.

Zain is the GM/GVP of Pixie and Open Source at New Relic. He is also an Adjunct Professor of Computer Science at Stanford University. He was the Co-founder/CEO of Pixie Labs.

Read More